Investing for College in the US (2025 Edition): A Slow Money Guide for Families
Introduction: The American College Dream, the Debt Dilemma, and the Slow Money Path
For generations, sending a child to college has been one of the great markers of the American dream. It symbolizes opportunity, independence, and the promise of a better life. But in 2025, that dream comes with a sobering reality: the price tag. For many families, it feels less like a milestone to celebrate and more like a financial storm gathering on the horizon.
The numbers are staggering. In-state tuition at public four-year universities now averages around $11,500 per year, a 15% rise in just the past decade. Out-of-state students pay closer to $29,000 annually, and private universities average $42,000 or more. Add housing, meals, books, and travel, and the real cost of a degree can easily stretch into $100,000–$250,000. At elite private institutions, it’s edging toward $350,000.
This isn’t just abstract accounting — it’s reshaping family life. Parents sit at kitchen tables, weighing hard choices. Should we increase our retirement contributions or put more aside for college? Do we trim vacations, hobbies, even medical treatments, to spare our children from debt? Surveys show seven in ten American parents worry they won’t be able to afford their child’s higher education, and many report cutting back on personal goals to prioritize savings for their kids.
And hovering in the background is the cautionary tale of student debt. Over 43 million Americans carry student loans, with balances averaging $37,000 per borrower. Some owe much more. For young adults, these loans have become life-defining: dictating where they live, when they buy a home, or whether they feel ready to start a family. Parents who spent decades repaying their own loans are determined not to pass that burden to the next generation.
This dynamic creates an emotional push and pull. On one side is love — the deep desire to give your children freedom and choice. On the other side is fear — of sacrificing too much, of running out of time, of never saving “enough.” It’s easy to feel like you’re standing in a tug-of-war between your child’s future and your own financial security.
But here’s the quiet truth: you don’t need to do everything, and you don’t need to do it perfectly. The Slow Money philosophy reminds us that steady, consistent steps — even small ones — compound over time. A seed planted today doesn’t become a tree overnight, but nurtured patiently, it becomes shade for generations. In the same way, $50 a month into the right account can grow into thousands by the time your child reaches 18. The point isn’t to cover every dollar of tuition, but to reduce reliance on loans and create breathing room for your child’s choices.
The American system offers multiple tools to help families achieve this balance. Some, like 529 plans, are household names. Others, such as custodial UGMA/UTMA accounts, Roth IRAs for working teens, Coverdell ESAs, and even plain taxable brokerage accounts, are less familiar but equally important. Each has trade-offs: some offer tax breaks, others offer flexibility, and all require families to think carefully about what balance of control, growth, and freedom they need.
This guide, updated for September 2025, will walk you through each of these pathways in detail. We’ll examine the problems families face, explain the Slow Money solutions, break them down into practical steps, and illustrate them with real family stories. We’ll also look at the broader research, explore the psychological side of saving, and answer the most common questions parents ask.
At the end of the day, the goal is not to achieve a perfect financial strategy. It’s to give your child options — to enter adulthood with less debt, more freedom, and the ability to design a life they love. And it’s to give yourself peace of mind, knowing you’ve done what you can, steadily and thoughtfully, without losing sight of your own needs.
Just as a gardener doesn’t expect to harvest overnight, parents don’t need to save everything at once. The key is planting early, watering regularly, and letting time do its quiet work. That’s the Slow Money path: grounded, steady, and life-giving. And in a country where higher education carries both the weight of opportunity and the risk of debt, it’s the path that offers families the best chance at balance.
Pathway 1: 529 College Savings Plans — The Flagship of US College Investing
The Problem: Rising Costs and Parental Anxiety
College costs in the US have risen relentlessly for decades. A public university education, once attainable with part-time work and a modest family contribution, now carries a price tag that can rival the cost of a house. By 2025, tuition alone averages $11,500 a year for in-state students, $29,000 for out-of-state, and $42,000 for private universities. Add in housing and living expenses, and the total can easily exceed $250,000 for a bachelor’s degree.
For many families, these numbers feel overwhelming. Parents want to help but face doubts: What if I save too little? What if I save too much and my child doesn’t need it? Fear of “locking up” money in the wrong place stops some families from saving at all, leading to frantic last-minute borrowing.
The Slow Money Solution: 529 Plans
Enter the 529 plan, named after Section 529 of the Internal Revenue Code. It is the government’s flagship tool for college savings and, when used well, one of the most effective. The core advantages are simple but powerful:
Tax-free growth: Your investments grow without federal or state income tax.
Tax-free withdrawals: As long as funds are used for qualified education expenses.
State tax benefits: Over 30 states plus DC offer deductions or credits for contributions.
Flexibility: Funds can be transferred to siblings, cousins, or even rolled into a Roth IRA under SECURE 2.0 if unused.
In a world where families are desperate for clarity, the 529 provides structure: a dedicated account with rules that encourage saving, tax benefits that reward it, and investment options that keep pace with inflation.
Practical Steps: How to Use a 529 Wisely
Start Small, Start Early
Don’t wait for a windfall. Even $50/month from birth grows to nearly $20,000 by 18 at 6% growth. Think of it as planting seeds — small but steady watering leads to a flourishing tree.Compare State Plans
Don’t automatically default to your state’s plan. Compare fees and perks. Some states, like Indiana, offer a 20% state tax credit (up to $1,500 a year), while others, like California, offer no deduction at all. You can usually invest in any state’s plan.Choose Direct-Sold Over Advisor-Sold
Direct-sold plans from providers like Vanguard, Fidelity, and Schwab offer expenses as low as 0.10–0.20%. Advisor-sold plans can cost 0.70% or more, which over 18 years could mean tens of thousands lost to fees.Pick the Right Portfolio
Age-based portfolios shift from stocks to bonds as your child approaches college — ideal for most families.
Static portfolios let you choose a fixed mix (e.g., 80% stocks).
Individual funds give maximum choice, including ESG options.
Use the Superfunding Rule
Wealthier families can “front-load” up to $90,000 per parent ($180,000 per couple) in 2025, treating it as spread over five years for gift-tax purposes. This jumpstarts compounding.Know What Counts as Qualified Expenses
Tuition, room and board, books, and required technology qualify. So does up to $10,000/year for K-12 tuition and $10,000 lifetime for student loan repayment.Coordinate with Grandparents
FAFSA reforms (effective 2024) reduced the penalty for grandparent-owned 529 withdrawals. Now, grandparents can contribute without fear of wrecking financial aid.Plan for Scholarships
If your child earns a scholarship, you can transfer funds to another family member or roll up to $35,000 lifetime into their Roth IRA. No savings effort is wasted.Balance with Retirement
It’s tempting to pour everything into a 529, but remember: you can borrow for college, not for retirement. Maintain balance.Automate Contributions
Set up automatic transfers so saving becomes routine, not a monthly decision. Families who automate are far more likely to stay consistent.
Top-rated options include Utah’s my529, which Morningstar awarded a Gold rating for its ultra-low fees and customizable portfolios, and New York’s 529 Direct Plan (Vanguard/Ascensus), consistently ranked among the nation’s best-value programs. Fidelity’s 529 offerings (including those in New Hampshire, Massachusetts, and Delaware) are praised for ease of use and no minimums, while College Savings Iowa, managed by Vanguard, has frequently topped Morningstar’s list for low-cost, straightforward investing.
A Slow Money Perspective
The 529 embodies the Slow Money philosophy: it rewards consistency, patience, and steady growth. It’s not about sudden windfalls or speculative bets, but about planting regularly, letting time compound your effort, and knowing that even small seeds grow into strong trees.
Vignette: The Patel Grandparents
Arjun’s grandparents in Indiana wanted to help with his future but also ease their own taxes. By contributing $7,500/year to his 529, they received a 20% state tax credit worth $1,500 annually. Over 15 years, their contributions grew into six figures, while saving them nearly $20,000 in state taxes. The plan not only built Arjun’s college fund but also created an annual rhythm of generosity that became part of the family story.
Pathway 2: UGMA/UTMA Custodial Accounts — Flexibility with a Trade-Off
The Problem: Families Want Options Beyond Tuition
For all their strengths, 529 plans come with a limitation: funds must be used for qualified education expenses. Yes, the list has expanded to cover K–12 tuition and even some student loan repayment, but what if your child doesn’t follow a traditional path? What if they decide to start a business, buy a home, or pursue a trade? What if they delay college entirely?
Parents and grandparents increasingly want flexibility. They don’t want every dollar “locked” to tuition when life may take unexpected turns. At the same time, they want to invest in real assets — not just let money sit in a savings account — and they’d like their children to gain experience managing money before adulthood.
This is where custodial accounts come in, through two versions: UGMA (Uniform Gifts to Minors Act) and UTMA (Uniform Transfers to Minors Act).
The Slow Money Solution: UGMA/UTMA Accounts
A custodial account is an investment account set up for a child but managed by an adult (the “custodian”) until they reach legal adulthood — usually age 18 or 21, depending on the state.
Unlike 529 plans, custodial accounts:
Aren’t limited to education. Funds can be used for any purpose that benefits the child.
Allow broader investment choices. You can invest in stocks, bonds, ETFs, and mutual funds.
Teach financial responsibility. Teens can see their account balances, watch investments grow, and begin to learn.
The trade-off? Control. Once the child comes of age, the account is legally theirs. That $50,000 you’ve carefully built could go toward college tuition — or a convertible car. That risk requires honest conversations and intentional planning.
Practical Steps: Using Custodial Accounts Effectively
Choose UGMA vs UTMA
UGMA: Limited to financial assets (stocks, bonds, cash).
UTMA: Broader — can include real estate or property.
Most families choose UTMA for flexibility, though brokers often label both simply as “custodial accounts.”Pick a Low-Cost Broker
Fidelity, Schwab, and Vanguard all offer custodial accounts with no maintenance fees and access to index funds.Understand the Kiddie Tax
Unearned income above a threshold (about $2,600 in 2025) is taxed at the parent’s rate, not the child’s. This prevents wealthy families from sheltering large amounts. Still, the first portion is taxed at the child’s lower rate, making small accounts efficient.Balance Contributions
Remember: once the money is in, it’s irrevocably the child’s. Don’t overfund. Use custodials for flexibility, but keep retirement and 529 savings balanced.Teach Transparency
Show older kids how markets work. Review quarterly statements together. Frame it as a long-term project, not spending money.Blend with a 529
Many families split: 529 for tuition, custodial for flexibility. This dual approach covers both “expected” and “unexpected” paths.Prepare for the Transfer
At age 18 or 21, the money becomes legally theirs. Use the years leading up to this to build financial literacy. Don’t just hand them a lump sum; walk them through what it represents.Think About Financial Aid
Custodial accounts are considered the student’s asset for FAFSA purposes, which can reduce aid eligibility more than parent-owned assets. For high-need families, a 529 may be smarter.Consider Tax-Loss Harvesting
For larger accounts, some parents use custodials to teach kids about tax-efficient investing, turning it into a practical lesson.Keep Perspective
Custodials are about balance — giving teens flexibility without overwhelming them. Even a modest account can be meaningful if paired with guidance.
When choosing a provider, credibility matters. Fidelity’s Youth Account was named Best Brokerage for Beginners 2025 by NerdWallet, making it an excellent choice for families. Charles Schwab, a frequent J.D. Power award winner for customer satisfaction, also offers strong custodial platforms, while Vanguard’s low-cost index funds continue to make it a trusted long-term option.
A Slow Money Perspective
Custodial accounts reflect the Slow Money ethos of teaching by doing. Instead of sheltering children from financial responsibility until they’re suddenly adults, you bring them into the process gradually. Watching a $1,000 investment grow to $1,500, then dip back to $1,300, then recover again is a lived lesson in patience and resilience.
Yes, there’s a risk that at 21, your child makes an unwise choice. But there’s also a gift: the chance to learn with real stakes while still having you nearby as a guide. Money is never just numbers — it’s a relationship. Custodial accounts let you shape that relationship slowly, deliberately, with a mix of trust and teaching.
Vignette: The Johnson Family
The Johnsons in Ohio weren’t sure if their son Alex would go to college. He loved cars, dreamed of opening a repair shop, and wasn’t drawn to academic life. Rather than put everything into a 529, they opened a custodial UTMA at Schwab. Contributing $5,000 a year, they invested in broad-market ETFs.
By the time Alex turned 21, the account had grown to $40,000. With guidance from his parents, he used part of it for trade school tuition and the rest to buy equipment for his shop. For the Johnsons, the custodial account wasn’t just money — it was an act of faith in Alex’s unique path.
Pathway 3: Custodial Roth IRAs for Teens — Planting the Retirement Seed Early
The Problem: Teenagers Earn, but Rarely Save
Every summer, millions of American teenagers pick up part-time jobs — scooping ice cream, lifeguarding, tutoring, babysitting, or working retail. For many, it’s their first taste of independence and their first paycheck. Yet almost all of that money gets spent quickly: sneakers, concerts, gas for the car, or meals out with friends. While spending is part of learning, the opportunity to build long-term wealth often slips away.
Parents feel the tension. You want your teen to enjoy their earnings — after all, they worked hard for them. But you also know that the earlier money is invested, the more powerful compounding becomes. A dollar saved at 16 can grow to $20 or more by retirement. The question is: how do you encourage saving without killing your teen’s enthusiasm or making them feel punished for working?
The Slow Money Solution: Custodial Roth IRAs
The Roth IRA is one of the most powerful tools in personal finance. Contributions go in after tax, grow tax-free, and can be withdrawn tax-free in retirement. Normally, kids can’t open retirement accounts — but a custodial Roth IRA solves that problem. Parents (or grandparents) act as custodians, managing the account until the child reaches adulthood (usually 18 or 21).
The key requirement is that the teen has earned income. Babysitting counts. W-2 jobs count. Lawn mowing for neighbors counts. Allowances or gifts do not. As long as there’s verifiable earned income, the teen can contribute up to the annual IRA limit ($7,000 in 2025), or the total they earned — whichever is less.
This creates a unique opportunity: teenagers can start their retirement savings decades earlier than most adults. The combination of small contributions and decades of compounding turns modest sums into life-changing wealth.
Practical Steps: How to Use a Custodial Roth IRA
Confirm Earned Income
Babysitting, part-time jobs, internships, and freelance gigs qualify. If your teen made $3,000 last summer, they can contribute up to $3,000 to a Roth IRA.Open at a Major Broker
Fidelity, Vanguard, and Schwab all offer custodial Roth IRAs with no minimums. Setup is simple, and custodianship transfers automatically when the child reaches adulthood.Contribute on Their Behalf
If your teen doesn’t want to part with their paycheck, you can “match” it. For example, if they earn $2,000 but want to keep it, you can gift $2,000 into the Roth as long as it doesn’t exceed their earned income.Invest Simply
Use target-date retirement funds or broad-market index funds. Teens don’t need complex strategies; they need consistency.Teach the Power of Compounding
Show your teen the math: $1,000 invested at 16 could grow to nearly $20,000 by 65 at 7% growth. A single summer’s effort can ripple across a lifetime.Highlight Early Withdrawal Rules
While Roth contributions are meant for retirement, contributions (not earnings) can be withdrawn penalty-free at any time. That means if your child needs money for college or a first home, the Roth can double as a flexible backup.Frame It as Freedom, Not Sacrifice
Instead of saying, “You can’t spend your paycheck,” explain that this is about buying freedom later. The message should be: you’re not losing money, you’re gaining options.Celebrate Milestones
When the balance hits $1,000, mark the occasion. When dividends arrive, show them how “money makes money.” Turning savings into a tangible win builds motivation.Blend with Other Accounts
Use 529s for college, custodial accounts for flexibility, and Roth IRAs for long-term security. Each has its place.Encourage Ongoing Contributions
Even small amounts — $500 each summer — can make a huge difference if started young.
Families looking for providers should note that Fidelity’s custodial Roth IRA was named Best Account for Teens 2025 by Forbes Advisor, thanks to its no-fee structure and ease of setup. Schwab’s Roth IRA for Minors is also recognized for its educational support, while Vanguard’s award-winning target-date funds remain a simple, cost-efficient choice for hands-off investors.
A Slow Money Perspective
Custodial Roth IRAs reflect the deepest values of the Slow Money approach. They embody patience, time, and the long view. It’s not about fast returns or flashy wins, but about teaching your child to plant acorns today that become oak trees tomorrow.
They also shift the family dynamic: saving becomes a partnership. Parents match contributions, teens contribute earnings, and together they watch wealth quietly grow. It turns money from a short-term indulgence into a shared story about building freedom.
Vignette: Chloe’s First Roth
Chloe, a 17-year-old in Oregon, worked weekends at a local café, earning $5,000 during the year. Her parents wanted her to enjoy her earnings, but they also wanted her to learn about investing. They offered to “match” $2,500 of her earnings into a custodial Roth IRA at Fidelity.
Together, they chose a target-date fund aimed at 2065. Chloe was skeptical at first — why lock money away for decades? But when her dad showed her that the $2,500 could grow to nearly $80,000 by retirement at average market returns, her eyes widened. Suddenly, saving didn’t feel like deprivation. It felt like empowerment.
By age 18, Chloe not only had a nest egg but also a story — the story of how one teenage job turned into a foundation for her financial future.
Pathway 4: Coverdell ESAs — The Overlooked but Useful Option
The Problem: Small Limits, Big Confusion
In the world of college savings, Coverdell Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) often feel like the forgotten cousin. Most parents have heard of 529 plans, but when Coverdells come up, the reaction is usually: “Didn’t those disappear?” or “Aren’t they outdated?”
The truth is that Coverdell ESAs are still around in 2025, and while their contribution limits are modest, they carry unique benefits. Many families dismiss them because they only allow $2,000 per year per child in contributions. Compared to the six-figure balances possible in a 529, that feels like a drop in the bucket. Add income limits (contributions phase out above $220,000 for married couples filing jointly), and it’s easy to see why they’re underused.
But the limitations can mask real strengths. Coverdells offer broader investment flexibility than many 529s, and they can be used for K–12 expenses as well as higher education. For the right family, they can be an effective supplement — not a replacement — to other savings tools.
The Slow Money Solution: A Flexible Complement
A Coverdell ESA works much like a 529 at its core: contributions grow tax-free, and withdrawals for qualified education expenses are also tax-free. Where it differs is in scope and flexibility:
Qualified expenses are broader: In addition to tuition, room, board, books, and technology, Coverdells can cover K–12 tuition, tutoring, uniforms, and even certain supplies.
More investment choices: Unlike many 529s, which restrict you to a menu of funds, Coverdells often allow you to invest in individual stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds. This appeals to families who want more control.
Better for private school families: Families paying for private middle or high school often find Coverdells uniquely helpful.
Of course, the trade-offs remain: low annual contribution limits and income restrictions. But in a Slow Money framework, Coverdells are not about replacing a 529. They’re about filling gaps, especially for families who value choice or who face regular K–12 expenses.
Practical Steps: Making the Most of a Coverdell ESA
Check Eligibility
Contributions phase out for couples earning above $220,000 AGI ($110,000 single). High-income families may be excluded, but grandparents can sometimes contribute instead.Open at the Right Broker
Many major firms (Fidelity, Schwab, TD Ameritrade) offer Coverdell ESAs with low or no account fees. Look for broad investment menus.Contribute Consistently
While $2,000/year may seem small, over 18 years that’s $36,000 in contributions. Invested at 6% growth, it can grow to $55,000+. Think of it as a supplemental fund, not the whole solution.Use for K–12 Expenses
If your child attends private school, Coverdells can cover tuition, tutoring, or even uniforms. This makes them more versatile than many 529s.Invest Strategically
Since balances are smaller, consider broad-market ETFs or mutual funds that keep costs low but growth potential high. Avoid speculative picks — this money has a purpose.Coordinate with a 529
Use the 529 for large college costs, and Coverdells for K–12 or niche expenses. For example, if you’re saving $500/month overall, you might put $450 into a 529 and $50 into a Coverdell.Withdraw by Age 30
Funds must be used by the time the beneficiary turns 30 (with some exceptions). If not, you’ll pay taxes and penalties. One workaround: transfer to another eligible family member.Think About Grandparents
If parents are above the income limit, grandparents may still qualify to contribute. This can be a tax-efficient way to support education across generations.Track Carefully
Coverdells don’t have the same robust tracking tools as 529s. Keep receipts for K–12 expenses in case of IRS questions.Keep Perspective
Coverdells aren’t a magic bullet. But for the right family, they provide a helpful edge — especially if you’re already maxing out other options.
While Coverdells are less widely publicized, strong brokers still support them. Fidelity, highlighted in NerdWallet’s 2025 reviews for its broad fund access, remains a popular choice, while TD Ameritrade (now Schwab) continues to be recognized for its investor education and range of investment tools.
A Slow Money Perspective
Coverdells remind us that not every tool has to be big to be meaningful. Think of them as a side garden plot: small, but capable of producing a steady harvest that complements the main field. They’re not going to feed the whole family, but they can provide essential variety and flexibility.
For parents, they represent an intentional choice: to use every available avenue, even smaller ones, to create freedom for their children. In a world obsessed with scale and speed, Coverdells are a reminder that small, steady contributions can still matter.
Vignette: The Sanders Family
The Sanders family in Massachusetts sent their twins to a private Catholic school. Tuition for middle and high school averaged $10,000/year per child. By funding $2,000/year into each child’s Coverdell from kindergarten onward, they built a reserve that covered tutoring, uniforms, and laptops.
By the time college arrived, the twins also had modest 529 accounts. The Coverdells didn’t pay for everything — but they reduced strain during the K–12 years, freeing the family to keep contributing to 529s for college. For the Sanders, the Coverdells weren’t flashy. They were practical, steady, and exactly what the family needed.
Pathway 5: Taxable Parent Accounts — Flexibility Without Strings
The Problem: Not Every Dollar Fits Into a Box
For many families, 529s, Coverdells, and custodial accounts all sound useful — until you read the fine print. Every one of them comes with strings attached: qualified expenses, age limits, income limits, financial aid implications, or the risk of losing control when a child turns 18 or 21. Parents who value flexibility often feel boxed in.
Imagine you’re saving diligently for college, but halfway through, your child wins a scholarship or decides to attend a community college for two years before transferring. Suddenly, the carefully sheltered 529 feels like a trap: if you use it for non-education expenses, you’ll face taxes and penalties. Or maybe your child decides college isn’t for them at all, preferring trade school, entrepreneurship, or a gap year. Do you really want every dollar tied to tuition?
This desire for freedom leads many parents to consider the simplest, most flexible option: a plain taxable brokerage account in their own name.
The Slow Money Solution: Taxable Accounts
A taxable brokerage account is just what it sounds like — an ordinary investment account that you own and control. There are no contribution limits, no age restrictions, no penalties for using the money however you like. You can open one at Fidelity, Vanguard, Schwab, or countless other brokers, and invest in virtually anything: index funds, ETFs, stocks, bonds.
Of course, you don’t get the tax perks of a 529 or the flexibility of tax-free withdrawals in a Roth IRA. You’ll pay capital gains tax when you sell investments at a profit, and dividends are taxed along the way. But for many parents, the trade-off is worth it: complete control and flexibility.
Think of taxable accounts as the Swiss Army knife of education planning. They don’t specialize in one thing, but they’re always useful, no matter the path your child takes.
Practical Steps: Using Taxable Accounts for College Savings
Open with a Trusted Broker
Fidelity, Vanguard, and Schwab offer easy-to-use platforms with low-cost ETFs and mutual funds. Many allow automatic transfers.Earmark Mentally
Create a “college sub-account” within your brokerage. This keeps education savings mentally separate from other investments, even if technically it’s all your money.Invest Tax-Efficiently
Use ETFs (exchange-traded funds) that minimize taxable distributions. Consider municipal bonds for predictable, tax-advantaged income.Automate Contributions
Treat it like a 529: set up monthly transfers so saving becomes a habit.Blend with Other Tools
Don’t think of taxable accounts as either/or. Many families split: 529 for tax benefits, custodial for flexibility, and taxable for “just in case.”Keep Retirement Separate
Avoid the temptation to use retirement accounts as education accounts. Taxable brokerage funds are better for flexibility without endangering your own long-term security.Teach Your Teen
Show them how real-world investing works. Let them see the difference between dividends, growth, and taxes.Plan Withdrawals Wisely
Selling in a high-income year can mean more taxes. Consider timing withdrawals when your income is lower or spreading them across multiple years.Think Multi-Purpose
If your child gets a scholarship, you can repurpose the account for home improvements, travel, or even your own retirement bridge. No dollar is wasted.Stay Disciplined
The risk with taxable accounts is also their strength: flexibility. Without restrictions, it’s easy to raid the fund for other goals. Protect the boundary with intentionality.
For taxable accounts, Fidelity, named Best Overall Broker 2025 by Investopedia, is an outstanding option for families who want simplicity and broad fund access. Schwab, a consistent J.D. Power award-winner for investor satisfaction, combines low fees with strong customer support. Vanguard also maintains its reputation for transparency and low-cost index investing, making all three excellent choices for long-term family flexibility.
A Slow Money Perspective
Taxable accounts reflect a grounded philosophy: sometimes simplicity wins. In a world full of fine print, tax codes, and special rules, having money in your own name — free to use as you see fit — is liberating.
In Slow Money terms, a taxable account is like planting an orchard instead of just one crop. Some harvest may go to college, some to other goals, but the orchard itself grows steadily. You’re not locked into one use, and you can adapt as life unfolds. That adaptability is worth more than the tax perks you give up.
Vignette: The Carters’ “Flex Fund”
The Carters in Colorado had two kids but weren’t sure if either would attend a traditional four-year university. Instead of putting everything into 529s, they split their savings. Half went into 529s for the tax benefits, and half into a taxable brokerage they nicknamed their “flex fund.”
Over 15 years, the taxable account grew to $60,000. When their daughter chose a trade school and their son earned a partial scholarship, the Carters felt no stress. They used the taxable funds for gap-year travel, trade school tuition, and eventually part of a down payment on a family home.
For them, flexibility was the ultimate benefit. By refusing to lock every dollar into tuition, they created space for life’s surprises — and ensured their savings never went to waste.
Research & Data: The Numbers Behind College Savings in 2025
When it comes to saving for college, opinions and anecdotes matter — but the numbers tell the real story. Let’s look at the research shaping how American families are approaching education costs in 2025.
The Rising Cost of College
The trend is unmistakable: college costs have outpaced both inflation and wage growth for decades. According to the College Board’s 2025 data:
Average in-state tuition and fees at public four-year colleges: $11,500 per year.
Average out-of-state tuition: $29,000 per year.
Average private university tuition: $42,000 per year.
Average room and board across institutions: $12,000–$15,000 per year.
That means a four-year degree can easily cost $100,000–$250,000, not counting extras like travel, laptops, or health insurance.
The long-term trend is even more sobering. Since 2000, tuition at public universities has risen by nearly 65% after inflation. Meanwhile, median household income has grown by just 20%. Families are being asked to shoulder a far greater burden relative to their earnings.
Student Debt: The Looming Shadow
The student debt crisis continues to shape the psychology of saving. The Department of Education reports that:
43 million Americans carry student loan debt.
The average federal borrower balance is around $37,000.
About 1 in 7 borrowers owes more than $50,000.
While relief programs have eased payments for some, the reality is that loans delay key life milestones. Surveys from Pew Research in 2025 found that 62% of borrowers delayed buying a home because of student loans, and 47% delayed starting a family. Parents take these statistics personally: they want their children to have choices unencumbered by debt.
How Families Are Saving
Despite the challenges, more families are taking proactive steps. The College Savings Plans Network (CSPN) reports:
529 plan usage has climbed steadily. As of 2025, there are more than 16 million 529 accounts nationwide.
The average balance in a 529 is just over $30,000 — enough to cover roughly two years at an in-state public university.
About 37% of families with children under 18 have some form of dedicated college savings, up from 30% a decade ago.
Interestingly, grandparents are playing a bigger role. Fidelity’s 2025 survey found that 40% of grandparents contribute to 529s or other education accounts. Many see it as a way to support their grandchildren while reducing the taxable value of their estate.
State Tax Incentives
One of the biggest drivers of 529 adoption is state-level tax perks. In 2025:
Over 30 states plus DC offer either deductions or credits for contributions.
Indiana remains the most generous, with a 20% state tax credit (up to $1,500 per year).
Pennsylvania allows deductions for contributions to any state’s plan — not just its own — giving families maximum flexibility.
New York offers deductions up to $5,000 ($10,000 for married couples).
California, Florida, and Texas don’t offer deductions (due to no state income tax), but residents still benefit from federal tax-free growth.
Families often don’t realize that they can invest in any state’s plan, not just their home state. Choosing based on low fees and strong investment options is often smarter than chasing a modest deduction.
FAFSA and Financial Aid
A key 2024 change is reshaping how families plan: under the updated FAFSA rules, withdrawals from grandparent-owned 529s are no longer counted as untaxed income for the student. This removes a major barrier that once discouraged grandparents from contributing. As a result, financial planners expect even more multigenerational funding strategies to emerge.
The Bigger Picture
All of this data points to one conclusion: families are becoming more intentional. They know college won’t pay for itself, and they’re using every tool available — from 529s to custodial accounts — to chip away at the looming costs. The average balances may not cover everything, but they don’t have to. Even a few years of tuition covered upfront can dramatically reduce a child’s reliance on loans.
And in the Slow Money spirit, the numbers reinforce the philosophy: small, steady contributions matter. The average 529 account balance of $30,000 didn’t come from lump sums. It came from parents automating $100 or $200 a month, grandparents adding birthday gifts, and families sticking with the plan year after year.
Tax Implications of College Savings Accounts in the US (2025)
When planning for college, taxes play a huge role in determining which accounts make the most sense. Parents often wonder: Will I lose my tax benefits if my child doesn’t attend college? Do I get a deduction for contributing? How do withdrawals affect my return? Let’s break it down account by account.
529 Plans
529s are the most tax-advantaged option. Contributions are made with after-tax dollars — there is no federal tax deduction. However, more than 30 states and DC offer deductions or credits for contributions, saving families hundreds each year. Earnings grow tax-free, and withdrawals for qualified education expenses are also tax-free.
If funds are used for non-qualified purposes, you’ll owe income tax on the earnings plus a 10% penalty. SECURE 2.0 adds flexibility by allowing up to $35,000 to be rolled into a Roth IRA for the beneficiary, avoiding waste if funds go unused.
UGMA/UTMA Custodial Accounts
Custodial accounts don’t have special tax breaks, but they do shift some income into the child’s tax bracket. The first ~$1,300 of unearned income is tax-free, the next ~$1,300 is taxed at the child’s rate, and anything above ~$2,600 is taxed at the parent’s rate (the “kiddie tax”). While this isn’t as efficient as a 529, it can still reduce the family’s tax bill slightly for modest accounts.
When assets are sold, gains are taxed at capital gains rates. Once the child reaches adulthood, the account becomes theirs — and future taxes are their responsibility.
Custodial Roth IRAs for Teens
Custodial Roth IRAs carry the same tax benefits as adult Roth IRAs: contributions are made after-tax, earnings grow tax-free, and withdrawals in retirement are tax-free. Teens can only contribute what they earn, but parents can fund contributions on their behalf. Contributions can also be withdrawn at any time, tax- and penalty-free.
If used for college, earnings withdrawn before age 59½ are subject to income tax but not the 10% penalty. This makes Roth IRAs a useful “backup” education fund, though their primary purpose should remain retirement.
Coverdell ESAs
Coverdells, like 529s, grow tax-free and allow tax-free withdrawals for qualified education expenses. The big limitations are the $2,000 annual contribution cap and income restrictions (phase-outs above $220,000 for joint filers). Used properly, they’re tax-efficient for families with modest K–12 and college costs, but less impactful for higher earners.
Taxable Brokerage Accounts
Taxable accounts offer no special education-related tax benefits. Dividends and interest are taxed annually, and capital gains are taxed when investments are sold. The upside is flexibility: money can be used for any purpose, and long-term capital gains are taxed at favorable rates (0%, 15%, or 20% depending on income).
Parents using taxable accounts should invest tax-efficiently — for example, using index ETFs with low turnover or municipal bonds for tax-free income.
Key Takeaways
529s: No federal deduction, but strong state benefits. Tax-free growth + tax-free withdrawals for education.
Custodial accounts: Some tax shifting to the child, but limited efficiency due to kiddie tax.
Roth IRAs: Tax-free growth for retirement, with flexibility to tap contributions for college.
Coverdells: Tax-free growth, but limited contributions and income restrictions.
Taxable accounts: No tax perks, but maximum flexibility.
A Slow Money Perspective
The tax system rewards consistency. Families who automate contributions to tax-advantaged accounts build up years of quiet compounding without annual tax drag. For higher earners, choosing the right mix of state-benefit 529s, Roth IRAs, and tax-efficient taxable accounts can mean tens of thousands saved over 18 years.
The key is not to chase perfection, but to understand the rules of each account and choose the blend that fits your family’s income, goals, and flexibility needs. Just as in gardening, each plant thrives in the right soil — your savings will thrive when placed in the right tax environment.
FAQs on College Savings in the US (2025)
1. What’s the difference between a 529 plan and a custodial account (UGMA/UTMA)?
A 529 plan is purpose-built for education. It offers tax-free growth, tax-free withdrawals for qualified expenses, and state tax benefits in many states. Custodial accounts, by contrast, can be used for anything — college, a car, even starting a business — but they don’t carry the same tax advantages. Another key difference is control: 529s remain under the parent’s or grandparent’s management indefinitely, while custodial accounts legally transfer to the child at 18 or 21, depending on the state.
In practice, many families use both. The 529 is the workhorse for predictable tuition costs, while a custodial account serves as a flexible backup. This way, you get the tax efficiency of a 529 without losing the freedom to support a child whose path might not follow a traditional four-year degree.
2. Can I lose money in a 529 plan?
Yes, 529 plans are investment accounts, not savings accounts. If you choose aggressive funds, your balance may fluctuate with the stock market. That said, most plans offer age-based portfolios that gradually shift from stocks to bonds and cash as the child approaches college age. This helps reduce the risk of a major downturn right before tuition bills come due.
It’s important to remember that volatility is part of long-term investing. Starting early allows you to weather short-term declines and benefit from decades of growth. Families who stay invested over time generally see steady compounding, even with temporary dips.
3. What happens if my child doesn’t go to college?
This is one of the most common concerns, and it stops many families from opening a 529. The good news is that 529s are more flexible than ever. You can:
Transfer funds to another child, sibling, or even yourself if you pursue further education.
Use up to $10,000 lifetime to repay student loans.
Roll over up to $35,000 to a Roth IRA for your child under the SECURE 2.0 Act.
These options ensure that your contributions don’t go to waste. At worst, if you withdraw funds for non-education purposes, you’ll pay income tax and a 10% penalty on the earnings portion (not contributions). But with today’s expanded rules, most families find ways to use the money productively.
4. How do 529 plans affect financial aid (FAFSA)?
Parent-owned 529 accounts are considered parent assets under FAFSA rules, which means they reduce aid eligibility by a maximum of 5.64% of their value. That’s far more favorable than student-owned accounts, which can reduce aid eligibility by 20%.
Grandparent-owned 529s used to cause problems because withdrawals counted as student income. But thanks to 2024 FAFSA reforms, that’s no longer the case. Grandparent 529 withdrawals are now ignored for aid purposes. This makes multigenerational saving strategies more attractive than ever.
5. Can grandparents contribute to 529s or other accounts?
Absolutely. In fact, grandparents are one of the fastest-growing sources of college savings support. They can open their own 529 for a grandchild, contribute to a parent-owned account, or even use custodial accounts.
The new FAFSA rules make grandparent 529s especially powerful, since withdrawals no longer hurt financial aid. Many grandparents also use 529 contributions as part of estate planning. By funding a 529, they reduce the size of their taxable estate while directly supporting education — a meaningful legacy that combines generosity with smart planning.
6. Should I save for retirement or college first?
Most financial planners agree: prioritize retirement. The reason is simple — you can borrow for college, but you can’t borrow for retirement. If you drain your future security to fund tuition, you may end up financially dependent on your children later.
That doesn’t mean you can’t do both. Many families strike a balance: max out employer retirement matches, then contribute what they can to a 529 or custodial account. Even modest contributions matter. The key is not to let guilt push you into shortchanging your own future. Your children need your financial stability as much as your tuition dollars.
7. Are taxable brokerage accounts a better idea than 529s?
It depends on your priorities. 529s are unbeatable for tax-free growth and education-specific savings. But taxable brokerage accounts offer complete flexibility. You can use the funds for college, a home renovation, or any other goal without penalties.
The trade-off is taxes: you’ll pay capital gains on investment growth in a taxable account, whereas 529 withdrawals for education are tax-free. Many families use both — 529s for the core of their education savings, and taxable accounts for “flex funds” in case their child’s path changes.
8. Can I change the beneficiary of a 529 plan?
Yes, and this flexibility is one of the 529’s greatest strengths. If your child doesn’t use all the funds, you can transfer the account to another sibling, cousin, parent, or even future grandchild without tax consequences.
This makes 529s especially attractive for families with multiple children. Contributions aren’t locked to one person forever; they can follow the educational needs of the family. That adaptability reduces the risk of “wasted” savings and ensures every dollar has a purpose.
9. Can 529s be used for student loan repayment?
Yes. Since 2019, 529 funds can be used to pay up to $10,000 lifetime per beneficiary in student loan debt. While this isn’t a huge amount relative to total tuition costs, it can make a difference in reducing balances after graduation.
Parents should be cautious, though. Using 529s for loans means those funds aren’t available for tuition in the first place. In most cases, it’s better to use 529s directly for education expenses and treat the loan repayment option as a backup.
10. How do Roth IRAs for teens actually work?
A Roth IRA for teens is essentially the same as for adults, but with a parent or guardian as custodian. Teens must have earned income (from a job, babysitting, or freelancing). They can contribute up to their total annual income or $7,000 in 2025, whichever is less.
Parents often “match” contributions. For example, if a teen earns $3,000 but wants to keep it, the parent can fund the Roth on their behalf. Contributions grow tax-free, and while the goal is retirement, teens can withdraw contributions (not earnings) penalty-free for education or a first home. It’s an incredibly powerful way to teach compounding and set a foundation for lifelong financial security.
11. What’s the difference between UGMA and UTMA accounts?
Both are custodial accounts, but with different rules on what assets they can hold. UGMA accounts are limited to financial assets like stocks, bonds, and mutual funds. UTMA accounts are broader, allowing property such as real estate.
In practice, most brokers treat them interchangeably, and most families stick to financial assets anyway. The bigger consideration is the age of transfer: 18 or 21 depending on your state. Once your child reaches that age, the money is legally theirs. That makes these accounts best for families who trust their teen’s maturity or who want to teach financial responsibility early.
12. Are Coverdell ESAs still relevant in 2025?
Yes — but only in specific situations. With a $2,000 annual contribution limit and income phase-outs at $220,000 for married couples, Coverdells aren’t a mainstay. But they’re useful for families who want broader investment options than 529s allow, or who have significant K–12 expenses.
For example, private school families often use Coverdells to pay for tutoring, uniforms, or laptops tax-free. They’re best used as a complement to 529s rather than a replacement. Think of them as a side plot in your financial garden — not the main field, but still worth planting.
13. Can I invest in individual stocks inside a 529?
Most 529 plans don’t allow individual stock purchases. Instead, they offer a curated menu of mutual funds and ETFs, often managed by providers like Vanguard, Fidelity, or TIAA. This keeps plans simple and reduces the risk of speculative investing.
If you want to invest directly in individual stocks, a custodial account (UGMA/UTMA) or taxable brokerage account may be better suited. For most families, though, the diversified fund options in 529s provide all the growth potential needed.
14. Do 529 contributions qualify for federal tax deductions?
No. Contributions to a 529 are not deductible on your federal income tax return. The tax advantages come from tax-free growth and withdrawals, plus state-level benefits in many places.
This is why comparing state plans is so important. The difference between a state offering a generous deduction (like New York or Indiana) versus none (like California) can amount to thousands over the years.
15. Can I use a 529 for trade schools or vocational programs?
Yes. 529 plans aren’t limited to traditional universities. Funds can be used at any accredited postsecondary institution, including trade schools, community colleges, and vocational programs.
This makes 529s a strong choice even if you’re not sure your child will attend a four-year college. From welding to coding bootcamps, many career paths qualify. Always check the Department of Education’s eligible institutions list before committing funds.
16. What happens if my child gets a scholarship?
If your child receives a scholarship, you can withdraw the equivalent amount from a 529 without paying the 10% penalty. You will, however, owe income tax on the earnings portion.
Alternatively, you can transfer the funds to another family member, save them for graduate school, or roll up to $35,000 into your child’s Roth IRA under SECURE 2.0 rules. These options ensure your savings effort doesn’t go to waste.
17. Can I hold both a 529 and a custodial account?
Yes, and many families do. In fact, combining them often provides the best balance. The 529 covers tuition with tax-free efficiency, while the custodial account adds flexibility for non-education goals.
The key is balance. If you put everything into custodials, you miss out on tax breaks. If you put everything into 529s, you risk rigidity. By blending, you give your child both structure and freedom.
18. How do taxes work on custodial accounts?
Custodial accounts are subject to the “kiddie tax.” The first portion of unearned income (interest, dividends, gains) is taxed at the child’s rate. Once income passes about $2,600 (2025 threshold), additional earnings are taxed at the parent’s rate.
This makes custodials less efficient for large balances but fine for smaller accounts. Many families view the taxes as the cost of flexibility. Since custodials can be used for any purpose, the trade-off often feels worthwhile.
Conclusion: Choosing the Slow Money Path
Planning for college in America is no small task. The numbers can feel overwhelming: tuition rising faster than inflation, debt burdens reshaping young adulthood, and a system that often seems stacked against families trying to do the right thing. But behind the anxiety lies an opportunity — to approach college savings with clarity, balance, and intention.
The tools are here. 529 plans offer unmatched tax advantages and flexibility. Custodial accounts (UGMA/UTMA) provide freedom for children whose paths may not follow the traditional route. Custodial Roth IRAs allow working teens to plant retirement seeds decades early. Coverdell ESAs fill niches for K–12 families, while taxable accounts give parents maximum control. Each has trade-offs, but together they form a toolkit that adapts to almost any family story.
The deeper truth is that no family has to do this perfectly. You don’t need to cover every dollar of tuition to make a difference. Even modest, steady contributions compound into something meaningful. $50 or $100 a month may not sound like much today, but over 10–15 years, it can reduce loan balances, open doors, and give your child choices. In Slow Money terms, it’s like tending a garden — watering a little every week until the harvest arrives.
The goal isn’t just to fund a degree. It’s to give your child freedom: freedom from crushing debt, freedom to choose a career based on passion instead of paycheck, freedom to enter adulthood with confidence. And it’s to give yourself peace of mind: knowing you’ve taken intentional steps without sacrificing your own future security.
As you finish this guide, remember: the first step matters more than the perfect step. Open a 529. Automate a small transfer. Talk to your teen about money. Each small act is a seed, and with time, it grows into shade your family can rest under.
Ready to take action?
Compare top-rated 529s at Fidelity, Vanguard, or Schwab. Explore a custodial Roth if your teen is working. Blend taxable accounts for flexibility. And above all, keep moving forward — slowly, steadily, with purpose.
The American college dream doesn’t have to be weighed down by debt. With patience and the right tools, you can build a future where your children step into adulthood with options, not obligations. That’s the power of Slow Money.
© Slow Money Movement™ 2025. All content is provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. We are not financial advisers; please do your own research or consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions. Some posts contain affiliate links — if you choose to sign up or purchase through these, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the site and allows us to continue providing free resources and content. We only recommend reputable platforms and products that align with our values of safe, grounded finance.